November 16, 2011

Winners: Alvaro Archundia (1st place), James Thompson (2nd place), Vinal Lee & Derek Pufahl (3rd place) (TIE)

Contestants: Ann Reynolds, Kelly Webber, Dustin Riggins, Bethany Schramm, Haley Hanson, Derek Pufahl, Erinn Baker, Jenn Ramsey, Tyisha Wrice, Joshua Joseph Schmidt, Brooke Bossman, Sean Isaac Garner, Genavieve Anderson, Mike Grove, Megan Tomasiewics, Stephanie Schumacher, Leah Riley, Andrew Hobart, Alvaro Archundia, Alexie Mobley, James Thompson, Vinal Lee, Holly Geisman, Jeff Fryman, Zach Drees, Jacob M. Barry, Alexandria Ewing, Alex West, Liz Lofgren, Jordan Roy